Best Historical Fiction 2025: The Year of the Unforgettable Female Hero
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
I’m always looking for a good book, and this year’s reading list checked all the boxes: complex historical narratives, women defying expectations, and, of course, a great Christmas story. Here are my Best Historical Fiction 2025 reads, organized by theme!
Royalty, Romance, and Historical Escapism
These are the Best Historical Fiction 2025 books that pulled me into richly detailed worlds, balancing great history with intimate, personal stories.
Christmas with the Queen by Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb
I absolutely LOVED this book! It’s the perfect blend of historical charm, feeling like a cozy version of The Crown meets Downton Abbey. The authors masterfully wove together multiple storylines, offering accompanying love stories both “upstairs and downstairs.” A delightful surprise was the friendship that bloomed between the Queen and a young female journalist, giving us a wonderfully softer view of the Queen than is usually depicted. I also loved the champions of underrated women in male-dominated positions and spotted the fun Easter egg cameo of characters from their previous book, Last Christmas in Paris. Overall, I’m always looking for a good Christmas story, and this one definitely checked all the boxes for me this year.


Last Twilight in Paris by Pam Jenoff
This was one of my top favorites for the year—it truly had it all! The story starts with a magical tree where leaving a letter supposedly matches you with your soulmate. The plot quickly evolves into a complex quest involving a mysterious necklace, a decades-old mystery, a buried secret Nazi prison, and more. Jenoff weaves an emotionally powerful storyline across three generations, connecting them all with such a perfect punch at the end. This is a can’t-miss read.
Champions of Courage: Women Redefining Their World
These Best Historical Fiction 2025 stories feature female characters who fight against the expectations of their time, whether in the space program or during the Cold War.
Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid
I love Taylor Jenkins Reid for her ability to create female characters who bravely buck societal expectations of the past—even if they are not always entirely likable (think The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo). While that wasn’t the case in Atmosphere, this novel was an incredible ride that was heartbreaking in its own way. I could not put this book down! This book gave me a whole new appreciation for both the space program and the women who fought like hell to participate in it. This is a definite must-read!


The Women of Arlington Hall by Jane Healey
I’m so glad I found my way to this one! As a fan of Jane Healey’s previous works like Good Night From Paris, this book was a great dive into the Cold War era. It focuses on Cat, a female codebreaker working undercover for the US military to root out secret messages from Soviet spies. I adored the strong cast of characters, especially Cat’s friend group and the developing romance with another codebreaker. Most refreshing was the depiction of the strong mentorship between Cat and her male boss—it was wonderful to see men championing smart women in a historical book. Overall, a great read.
Magic and Mystery: The Supernatural and the Secret
These Best Historical Fiction 2025 books use elements of magic, crime, or hidden history to explore deeper themes of identity and power.
The Amalfi Curse by Sarah Penner
Sarah Penner once again brought her brand of magical realism to the table. She takes the abnormality of a town on the Amalfi Coast—a town that was magically passed over by pirates—and weaves a captivating story about a secret coven of witches protecting it. But at what cost? I loved how she made us care about and root for these women, highlighting the heartbreaking stakes that were on the line at the end. This is a must-read!


The Queens of Crime by Marie Benedict
This was such a fun one! The story opens with famous female mystery writers, including a very humanized Agatha Christie, being turned away from a male mystery writing club. To prove themselves worthy and stick it to the men, they decide to solve their own real-life crime instead—and man, do they succeed! If you enjoy a fun mystery with twists and turns, this one is a delightful read.
Depth and Dimension: Stories That Challenge and Resonate
These are the powerful books that stuck with me the longest, exploring complex relationships, morality, and identity.
The Jackal’s Mistress by Chris Bohjalian
This one might have actually been my favorite of the entire year, which was a surprise! I went in thinking it might be a cliché Civil War love story between a soldier and a woman from opposing sides, but there was so much more depth and dimension here. I loved the way Bohjalian went into the relationships between Libby and her former slaves (now freed servants) and the dynamics and dangers she faced from her neighbors. He did an amazing job depicting the truly complicated layers of feelings and motivations between the injured soldier and Libby’s family, adding important shades of gray to a complex era. I highly recommend it!


Under the Same Stars by Libba Bray
I’m so glad I came across this one! While most of Libba Bray’s books I’ve read (A Great and Terrible Beauty, The Diviners) have a strong supernatural element, this was a more straight historical fiction book with multiple, intertwining storylines. It was harsh and shattering, but in the best possible ways. All the characters were dealing with heartbreaking situations yet fighting for some sense of control and meaning. The narrative threads—held together by letters and a magical tree—all came together with a powerful emotional punch!
Six Days in Bombay by Alka Joshi
This was an incredibly interesting, whirlwind adventure! The central mystery—who was telling the truth, and did it matter?—kept me turning pages. There are so many layered and important themes to unpack here: identity, gender roles, cultural differences, and sexuality. I love how Joshi dealt with these topics and forced you to even root for the unexpected characters at times. Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this and highly recommend it.


The Book Club for Troublesome Women by Marie Bostwick
This was one of my favorite book club reads for the year. It provided such a great conversation starter about the power of books and the honest assessment of life. I loved watching the women form these extremely powerful bonds and unlikely friendships. The reading list they amassed pushed them so far out of their comfort zones and societal norms—it was a fascinating evolution to witness, and I very much enjoyed reading it. Definitely recommend!
Did any of your favorite books make my list? Let me know what your favorited were!
If you liked this list, make sure to check out more of my others Here!

Find more ways to spoil your inner bookworm!
Check out the Amaryllis Co. Shop, fully stocked with custom designs perfect for every book loving Amaryllis Girl! From shirts, mugs, wine glasses, and more, I have curated a shop with all of my favorites! SHOP HERE! You can also find my collection of bookish merchandise on Etsy.






























