A Look Back at the BEST Historical Fiction Books 2023
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
There were so many great historical fiction books that came out this year. And I devoured them all! So, this list was very difficult to whittle down. But here we go, in my humble opinion, the best historical fiction books 2023! And yes, they are in order of my faves! 😉

Weyward by Emilia Hart
This book brings all the feels. There is a reason why it’s top of my best historical fiction books 2023 list! It’s creepy, yet demonstrates the most amazing sibling loyalty and girl power. Weyward follows three generations of women who have the gift of magic. Their lives are in no way easy, but man, do they end up rising up in the end!
The Spectacular by Fiona Davis
Oh, how I love Fiona Davis! She never disappoints and The Spectacular is a prime example. For starters, I love how she gets into such interesting examples of New York history through major landmarks. The building itself is always brought into such detail it becomes a character itself. Radio City Music Hall was no exception. This story honestly went into a way different direction than I originally anticipated (I thought I was just reading about the Rockettes) but it made the book that much better! Prepare yourself for a crazy bomber, a Rockette turned detective and a liaison with one of the first ever psychological profilers to hunt down a serial killer. It’s a fantastic ride!


Lady Tan’s Circle of Women by Lisa See
All I can say is Wow! After my three wise men post last week you can probably see I’m interested in acupuncture and Eastern medicine. So, this book hit all the right notes for me. Not only was it informative, it entrenched you in the culture. Feet binding, concubines, the rules women memorized and HAD to live by. And yet this book also demonstrated the important community and strength women cultivated. Overall, this is a fantastic Five Star Must Read and very much earned its place on the best historical fiction books 2023 list!
The House is on Fire by Rachel Beanland
This book literally was on fire! Beanland manages to really get us into the minds of multiple varying perspectives of victims trapped in the famous Richmond theater fire. The amazing part was that these different perspectives were from varying class and races. She really managed to capture the reality of Southern slavery and the opportunity the fire offered for some. A fantastic read that shouldn’t be missed


The Secret Book of Flora Lea by Patti Callahan Henry
This one gets you feeling all the feelings! Fourteen year-old Hazel and her five-year old sister Flora are evacuated to a rural village from war-torn London. To distract her young sister, Hazel creates a fairy tale story of a magical place called Whisperwood, their own secret place where they can escape. The unthinkable happens and Flora disappears, leaving Hazel alone to grieve.
Years later Hazel is working at a rare book shop. She comes across a manuscript that somehow tells the story of Whisperwood. No one else had ever heard the story except for Hazel and Flora. Could Flora still be alive? Hazel is determined to find out.
Homecoming by Kate Morton
This is a dark one, but so amazingly good! A man takes a walk on Christmas morning and finds a family who all died in their sleep under a tree in Australia. The book then follows the mystery to discover what happened to them. Multiple generations are involved and I can’t begin to tell you the twists and turns the story takes. I was completely enthralled!


Did You Hear About Kitty Karr? by Crystal Smith Paul
I not only heard about Kitty Karr. I loved Kitty Karr! A famous Hollywood actress surprisingly leaves her entire estate to the St. John sisters, three young wealthy Black women. Why did she do this? What was their connection? Elise St. John is determined to figure out why and her sleuthing uncovers some major surprises and secrets.
London Seance Society by Sarah Penner
I love Sarah Penner! Her book The Apothecary’s Daughter was one of my favorites. This one was quite different from that, but was still fantastic. A medium, famous for using her seances to solve murders, teams up with a girl searching for answers about her sister’s death. The two travel to London and team up with the elite men’s only London Seance Society to discover what really happened. However, they end up suspecting that instead of solving the crime, they might actually be entangled in one themselves.


The Mitford Affair by Marie Benedict
This was a different one for me. For starters, I have to say I didn’t actually like a single one of the main characters. They were all awful, unlikeable people. But that’s what made this book so captivating. The story is about a premier British family that aligned and became part of Hitler’s inner circle. Benedict manages to capture how and why these women were sympathetic to Hitler. The result is a runaway train that you know can’t stop.
Good Night from Paris by Jane Healey
What a bold and strong heroine! I loved this protagonist’s bravery in the face of occupied France. This story is based on a true story and really brings to life some of the heroic sacrifices American expats made in Europe during WWII. Another bonus was a Cameo secondary character appearance of famous journalist, Dorothy Thompson, who will be an important figure in future Ruth books as well. 😉

Did any of these books make your short list for best books of 2023?
If you enjoyed this book list, make sure you check out Joyana’s other Book Lists HERE!
Find more ways to spoil your inner bookworm!
Are you a VIP Member yet? If you’re interested in seeing Joyana’s Bonus content and ALL of her past newsletters make sure you sign up today! JOIN HERE.
Have you read my FREE Triangle Short Story? Get your copy HERE!

Check out the Amaryllis Co. Shop, fully stocked with custom designs perfect for every book loving Amaryllis Girl! From shirts, mugs, wine glasses, and more, I have curated a shop with all of my favorites! SHOP HERE!


















